The Non-Negotiable Must-Haves for Your Print Shop’s Marketing Strategy

Running a thriving print shop isn’t just about having the best equipment or offering low prices. It’s about staying visible, relevant and persuasive in a noisy marketplace. The challenge? Big-box competitors and online print options are everywhere. They’ve got large budgets, automated systems and thousands of SKUs. But you’ve got something better: personalized service, local loyalty and the ability to move fast.

The trick is to make sure your marketing strategy reflects that. Here’s a breakdown of the must-haves your print shop needs in its marketing strategy to generate more leads, book more jobs and be seen as the “obvious” option in a crowded marketplace. Let’s dive in.

1. A Website That Sells (Not Just Describes)

Your website shouldn’t just exist to look good. It should convert visitors into paid customers who keep coming back. If you’re still using an old-school site that merely conveys information, you’re going to leave leads (and money) on the table.

Instead, your website needs to:

Explain what you offer and who it’s for
Include a strong value proposition above the fold
Highlight specialties (rush jobs, signage, business cards, etc.)
Make it easy to request a quote, upload artwork or place orders
Feature reviews, real photos of your work and trust signals

Think of your website as a strategic sales asset. Every word, every visual and every section must help convey your value and speak to your customer’s real needs.

2. Local SEO That Gets You Found Quickly

Your customers aren’t searching for “best printer in the country.” Instead, they’re quickly going on Google, Bing and other search platforms and searching:

“print shop near me”

“banner printing in [city]”

“fast business cards in [zip code]”

That’s where local SEO shines. It’s the best way to consistently rank on the first page of Google (and other search engines). To get started, make sure your Google Business Profile is fully optimized with:

High-quality photos
Updated hours and location
Service area locations and coverage
Relevant keywords in your description
Ongoing Google reviews from happy customers

Local directories like Yelp, Bing, and Apple Maps also matter. The more consistent your business info is across the web, the higher you’ll rank.

3. Paid Ads That Target Real Buyers

Google Ads can work wonders for print shops due to leads being ready to buy right now. Avoid broad, general ads like “Printing Services, Click Here.” They waste money on low-intent clicks.

Instead, run highly targeted campaigns based on buyer behavior:

“Same-Day Banner Printing in Knoxville”

“Rush Trade Show Printing. Local Pickup Available.”

“Custom Business Cards, Plus Free Design Included!”

Add site links to direct users to different product pages. Include call extensions. And track conversions, not just clicks. Smart ad targeting helps you beat bigger players who rely on volume over precision.

4. A CRM or Email List That Keeps You Top-of-Mind

Most print customers are repeat buyers. Once they find someone up to their standard, they tend to stay. But they don’t always come back unless you stay visible. That’s where an email list or CRM comes in.

Even a basic monthly email can drive orders:

“Planning a Spring Event? Let’s Get Those Signs Started.”

“Need a Business Card Refresh? Free Proofing This Month.”

“You Ordered Flyers Last November. Ready for Round Two?”

Don’t overthink it. Just stay in touch with helpful content, offers and reminders. If you’ve got a list of past clients, there’s money sitting in your inbox.

5. A Lead Magnet That Builds Your Pipeline

Lead magnets aren’t just for coaches or software companies. They work for print shops, too. Here’s how: offer a helpful, easy-to-digest piece of value in exchange for a visitor’s email.

Examples:

“The Trade Show Printing Checklist: Everything You Need for a Booth That Pops”

“Real Estate Printing Toolkit: Signs, Flyers and Door Hangers That Convert”

“Free File Prep Guide: Avoid Common Mistakes Before You Hit Print”

Once you have their contact info, you can nurture the lead with follow-up emails, exclusive discounts, or seasonal reminders. This is helpful for B2B and event-based buyers who might not be ready to order right now, but will be soon.

6. Use Real Photos Of Real Customers

If your website and social channels are filled with bland stock images, you’re missing a chance to connect. Especially since you’re a local business, people want to see the real people behind those beautifully designed business cards and flyers, including:

Your team in action
Machines printing real jobs
Banners, signs and cards you’ve created
Happy clients receiving (and using) their order
Your shop, including the presses, the setup and team members

Real photos build trust. They make your business feel legit. And they’re more likely to get shared and remembered. Set aside an hour a month to snap pics or hire someone to do a quick photo shoot.

7. Testimonials and Case Studies That Build Confidence

When someone’s deciding between you and a competitor, social proof often tips the scale. You want to make your reviews not only easy to find, but also showcase your value (and what makes you different). Make it easy to find:

Short reviews from real clients
Industry-specific feedback (B2B, event booths, real estate)
Case studies showing how you handled unique or urgent print jobs

You don’t need dozens of reviews early on. Just a few strong examples go a long way. If possible, include names, companies and even photos.

This one can’t be overstated. When someone sees a print shop with 112 Google reviews and another with 4, guess who gets the call?

Ask every happy customer to leave a review. Build it into your process. Send a quick text or email after the job is done with a link to your Google listing.

Pro tip: Incentivize your team to help with review outreach. A few reviews each week snowball quickly into dozens and they massively impact your rankings and reputation.

Generate More Printing Services Leads With These Must-Haves

If you’re a print shop owner trying to grow in 2025, you don’t need to copy the corporate giants. You just need a proven strategy that works for your business, your customers and goals.

Get your website right. Build a local presence. Use smart ads. Nurture leads. And if you’re too busy running your shop and need an expert team to do this for you, Slamdot can help.

We bring two decades of experience helping local businesses leverage digital marketing strategies with one goal: ROI. We helped GoTeez from Alcoa, Tennessee, upgrade their website design to showcase their custom print services.

Want to see how we can help you grow, too? Contact us today!

See More Helpful Tips