Most print shops are leaving money on the table. For example, a new business owner comes in needing business cards. You get the order, print it fast and maybe even throw in a handshake. Job done, right? Not even close.

Instead, what if that $50 order could have become a $500+ package? Or what if that one order turned into a repeat client who relied on you for signs, brochures, mailers and more?

The truth is: most people don’t know what they need until you show them. That’s where strategic upselling comes in. Not pushy or awkward. But value-driven and perfectly timed. If you run a print shop and want to increase revenue without constantly chasing new leads, this blog’s for you.

Why Upselling Works So Well in the Print Industry

People usually come to your print shop with one idea in mind.

“I need business cards.” “I need a yard sign.” “I need a brochure.”

But they’re often unaware of everything else that could support their goal. Maybe that new business owner ordering cards also needs loyalty cards, branded stickers, window decals or flyers for an upcoming grand opening. Maybe that real estate agent asking for one open house sign could use a full set of branded materials.

The goal with high-converting upsells isn’t just to make more money. It’s to solve more problems and position your printing services as a trusted partner.

Now, let’s dive into a step-by-step breakdown of how to do it.

Step 1: Identify the Ideal Upsell Clients

Not every customer is ready for more. But some are in a buying cycle that makes them open to bigger solutions. Start with these high-opportunity groups, including:

1. New Entrepreneurs

They’re often overwhelmed and under-informed. Someone opening a boutique, restaurant, gym or even an online business usually has no idea how much printed material they’ll need to launch and use for marketing.

Lead with:

• Business cards

• Storefront banners

• Grand opening signage

• Special loyalty cards

• Stickers and all kinds of decals

This is the perfect moment to position a “Business Launch Print Kit” as an easy way to check multiple items off their list in one place.

2. Real Estate Professionals

Agents are one of the most print-dependent professionals out there and they often buy one item at a time. That’s your opportunity to simplify and upsell. Start with yard signs or business cards, then upsell into:

• Brochures

• Sign riders

• Branded folders

• Event flyers for open houses

• Thank you and referral postcards

• Branded notepads, pens and accessories

Show them how their brand can look consistent and professional across every touchpoint.

3. Nonprofits and Event Planners

Many nonprofits or local groups regularly host fundraisers, galas or community events. They may just ask for a few posters, but if you show them what’s possible, they’ll likely need more, like:

• Banners

• Programs

• Tickets

• Table signage

• Step-and-repeat backdrops

Upselling here is about helping them create a cohesive and professional event experience.

Step 2: Package the Upsell (For High Conversions)

Nobody wants a random list of add-ons. They want to feel like they’re getting a full solution. That’s where bundling works wonders. Create 2–3 easy-to-understand packages for your top client types.

Example: Small Business Starter Package

• 500 flyers

• 1,000 business cards

• 1 large storefront banner

• 100 loyalty and reward cards

Example: Realtor Brand Builder Kit

• 100 brochures

• 3 yard signs

• 250 branded notecards

• 2 open house banners

• Custom-designed folder

The key here is simplicity. Packages feel like solutions. They feel curated and easy to buy, which lowers friction and boosts order value.

Step 3: Train Your Team to Plant the Seed

Your front desk staff or order takers should never just say, “Okay, we’ll get those business cards done for you.” Instead, they should be trained to say something like:

“Great! We’ll get those printed fast. Tons of new businesses we work with also order a banner or flyers for launch week. Want me to show you some popular options?”

When your team knows what products go together and how to suggest them in a casual, helpful way, your upsell potential skyrockets. And if you’re a one-person shop? Train yourself to make the ask.

Step 4: Use Your Website to Upsell Without Pressure

Your website can (and should) do some of the heavy lifting. Add product suggestions under each item like:

“People who ordered business cards also bought…” “Want to create a full set? Bundle and save instantly.”

Consider building a few “Print Kits” into your site that visitors can order or request quotes for, especially during high-demand times. This can also tie into your lead magnets and email sequences (if you have them) to pitch upgrades after the first order is placed.

Step 5: Add Value, Not Pressure

The golden rule of upselling: make it about the client’s goals, not your wallet. People can spot authenticity and it’s crucial to get this right. Ask:

What is this person trying to accomplish?

What other items would help them succeed?

What looks unprofessional or incomplete right now?

If you can answer those questions, the upsell becomes natural.

Bonus: Offer a Loyalty Discount for Bigger Orders

One way to encourage upgrades without a “salesy” pitch is to offer loyalty-based pricing. This can make your upsell even stronger by providing value and a great deal, including:

“Order three or more items and get 10% off.” “Bundle design services with print and save.” “First-time customers: 15% off when you build a brand kit.”

This gives people a reason to say yes, increases your order value and builds loyalty.

Your Existing Customers Are a Profit Goldmine

You don’t always need to chase more customers. Sometimes the best source of revenue is already in front of you. That’s where strategic upselling comes in. When you show up with helpful suggestions and well-packaged options, most clients will thank you with their business.

At Slamdot, we help print shops not only bring in more traffic, but also convert it better. That means stronger websites, email funnels, offers and conversion-focused messaging that turns one-off orders into ongoing relationships.

Ready to turn small orders into big results? Contact us today!

See More Helpful Tips